Excel Transcription Automation Complete Guide | VBA vs RPA vs AI Comparison

“I want to automate Excel transcription, but VBA seems too difficult…” “Even if I create a macro, no one will be able to fix it after I leave…”

Do you have these concerns?

There are several options for automating Excel transcription: VBA macros, RPA, and AI agents. This article compares the pros and cons of each method to help you find the best solution for your situation.

---

Why Excel Transcription Automation is Necessary

3 Problems with Manual Transcription

Problem 1: Errors Occur

When humans manually copy data, mistakes inevitably happen.

Error Type	Example	Frequency	Impact
Input errors	123→132	High	Medium
Copy-paste errors	Selection offset	Medium	High
Omissions	Skipping rows	Medium	High
Duplicate entry	Same data twice	Low	Medium

Problem 2: It Takes Time

Volume	Per Item	Total Time	Annual	Labor Cost
100 items	1 min	1.5 hours	20 hours	$500
500 items	1 min	8 hours	100 hours	$2,500
1000 items	1 min	16 hours	200 hours	$5,000

Problem 3: Person-Dependency

Tasks become “only XX can do this.” Risk of work stopping when the person is absent or leaves.

---

Automation Method 1: VBA Macros

What is VBA?

VBA (Visual Basic for Applications) is a programming language built into Excel. You can create macros to automate repetitive tasks.

Sample Code

Sub TranscriptionMacro()
    Dim i As Long
    For i = 2 To 100
        Sheets("Destination").Cells(i, 1).Value = Sheets("Source").Cells(i, 2).Value
    Next i
End Sub

Advantages

Advantage	Description	Effect
Zero cost	No additional cost if you have Excel	Budget-friendly
High flexibility	Any process can be implemented	Full customization
Fast processing	Processes thousands of rows instantly	Time savings
Works offline	No internet required	Use anywhere

Disadvantages (3 Traps)

Trap 1: Person-Dependency

Only the creator understands the code. Risk of becoming a “black box” after resignation or transfer.

Situation	Impact	Countermeasure
Creator quits	No one can fix it	Documentation
Error occurs	Long investigation time	Add comments
Spec changes	Cannot adapt	Handover

Trap 2: Fragility

Change	Impact	Frequency
Insert one row	Range shifts, breaks	High
Rename sheet	Error stops execution	Medium
Add column	Reference shifts	High

Trap 3: Security Risk

Running macros downloaded from the internet poses virus infection risks.

When VBA is Recommended

• You have a staff member good at programming
• Format is fixed and doesn’t change
• You have code review processes internally
• Someone can maintain it long-term

---

Automation Method 2: RPA

What is RPA?

RPA (Robotic Process Automation) uses software robots to mimic human operations automatically.

Major RPA Tools

Tool	Features	Price	Best For
UiPath	Enterprise-grade, high functionality	$500+/month	Large enterprises
WinActor	Japanese-made, good support	$300+/month	Mid-size companies
Power Automate	Microsoft-made, M365 integration	Included in M365	M365 users
Blue Prism	Enterprise-focused	$1000+/month	Large enterprises

Advantages

Advantage	Description	Effect
No coding required	GUI configuration (supposedly)	Low learning curve
Cross-system integration	Can operate beyond Excel	Horizontal automation
24/7 operation	Runs at night and weekends	Time creation
Logging	Processing history retained	Audit compliance

Disadvantages

Disadvantage 1: Programming Thinking Still Required

Although marketed as “No-Code,” scenario creation requires logical thinking.

Disadvantage 2: Weak to Screen Changes

Change	Impact	Frequency
Button position change	Error	System updates
Window size change	Error	Environment changes
System update	Error	Periodic

Disadvantage 3: High Cost

Monthly costs of hundreds of dollars can be a burden for SMBs.

When RPA is Recommended

• Large enterprise with budget
• Cross-system routine tasks
• Can assign dedicated operators
• Long-term investment possible

---

Automation Method 3: AI Agents

What is an AI Agent?

An AI that understands context to process and transcribe data. Unlike rule-based systems, it understands meaning.

Advantages

Advantage	Description	Effect
No setup required	Just upload files	Start today
Handles variations	Recognizes “Inc.” and “Corporation” as the same	Error reduction
No maintenance	Adapts flexibly to format changes	Low operation cost
No person-dependency	Anyone can use it the same way	BCP measures
Learning function	Gets smarter with use	Continuous improvement

Disadvantages

Disadvantage	Description	Countermeasure
Not 100% accurate	Human confirmation needed	Confirmation flow
Running costs	Pay-per-use billing	ROI calculation
No offline	Internet required	Network environment
Black box	Process not visible	Log review

When AI is Recommended

• Documents with varying formats
• Don’t want to depend on staff skills
• Want to start small and verify results
• Want to minimize maintenance costs

---

Comparison Table of 3 Methods

Item	VBA Macros	RPA	AI Agents
Initial cost	◎ Free	× High	○ Low
Running cost	◎ Free	× High	△ Medium
Implementation difficulty	× High	△ Medium	◎ Easy
Variation handling	× No	× No	◎ Yes
Format change resistance	× Weak	× Weak	◎ Strong
Person-dependency risk	× High	△ Medium	◎ Low
Scalability	○ Medium	◎ High	○ Medium

---

Totsugo’s Transcription Automation

Feature 1: PDF Matching to Prevent Errors

AI automatically matches invoice PDFs with order PDFs. Automates pre-transcription verification.

Feature 2: COREC → freee Transcription Automation

Automatically creates invoices in freee from COREC order data. Zero copy-paste between systems.

Feature 3: No Macros, No Maintenance

No code writing required. AI adapts flexibly even when formats change.

---

How to Choose

Recommendations by Situation

Situation	Recommendation	Reason
No budget	VBA	Free
Large enterprise with budget	RPA	Cross-system automation
Want to start immediately	AI	Same-day start
No one to maintain	AI	Prevents person-dependency
Many variations	AI	Flexible handling

---

ROI Calculation

For 100 monthly transcription tasks:

Metric	Before	After	Reduction
Transcription time	5 hours/month	0.5 hours/month	90%
Error count	3/month	0/month	100%
Overtime	3 hours/month	0 hours/month	100%

Annual cost savings:

• Labor reduction: ~$1,500 (labor cost conversion)
• Error prevention: ~$500 (response cost reduction)
• Total: ~$2,000 annual savings

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. Can I use it without knowing VBA?

A. Yes. Totsugo is no-code. No programming knowledge required.

Q. Can I use it alongside existing Excel macros?

A. Yes. Totsugo complements existing workflows.

Q. How long does implementation take?

A. Available same day. Account creation to file upload takes about 10 minutes.

Q. Is it secure?

A. Data is encrypted during processing and deleted afterward.

Q. Is there a free trial?

A. Yes. Try it free first.

Q. Should small businesses adopt this?

A. If you have 50+ monthly transcription tasks, it’s worth considering.

Q. Which should I choose: RPA or AI Agent?

A. If already running RPA, use both together. For new adoption, AI agents are easier to implement.

Q. What’s the AI accuracy?

A. 95%+ accuracy. When discrepancies exist, it prompts human confirmation.

---

Summary: “Eliminate Transcription” Not “Automate Transcription”

Approach	Method	Result	Recommendation
Speed up transcription	Typing practice	Has limits	×
Automate transcription	VBA/RPA	Maintenance costs	△
Eliminate transcription	AI	Fundamental solution	◎

Why not use the time spent learning macros for more valuable work?

👉 Try PDF Matching First